The Toronto Blue Jays are at a crossroads this off-season. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is the face of their franchise. He is entering the final year of his contract. He is set to become a free agent after the 2025 season. While the Blue Jays are eager to lock him into a long-term deal, negotiations have been challenging. Guerrero Jr. himself stated that the Blue Jays’ initial offer of $340 million was “not even close” to his expectations. Adding to the pressure, Guerrero Jr. has set a self-imposed deadline of February 17th for contract negotiations, coinciding with the start of spring training. With time running out, let’s delve into what a potential extension could look like for the young slugger.
Guerrero Jr.’s Current Contract and 2025 Salary
Currently, Guerrero Jr. is playing under a one-year, $28.5 million contract for the 2025 season, which he signed to avoid arbitration . This impressive figure marks the third-highest salary ever paid to an arbitration-eligible player in MLB history. Only Juan Soto in 2024 ($31 million) and Shohei Ohtani in 2023 ($30 million) earned more. This substantial salary for 2025 underscores Guerrero Jr.’s value and sets the stage for potentially groundbreaking figures in his upcoming contract negotiations.
Guerrero Jr.’s Market Value
At just 25 years old, 26 years old next month, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is already a four-time All-Star and has consistently ranked among the league’s top hitters. He boasts a career .863 OPS. He is coming off a season where he finished sixth in MVP voting. This further solidifies his status as one of baseball’s elite talents. It’s important to note that Guerrero Jr. is relatively young. Compared to other players who have signed mega-deals, he may have more prime years ahead of him. This makes him an exceptionally attractive long-term investment for any team.
Back in November of 2021, I went on a rant. I argued that Vladdy should have been the AL MVP that season instead of Shohei Ohtani.
Spotrac, a website that tracks sports contracts and salaries, projects Guerrero Jr.’s market value at a staggering 12 years and $427 million . This projection places him in the same elite financial tier as superstars like Mike Trout and Mookie Betts. However, some analysts believe that Guerrero Jr.’s unique combination of youth, talent, and marketability could command even more, potentially exceeding Shohei Ohtani’s $437.8 million contract .
Recent Contract Extensions for Top MLB Players
To gain a clearer understanding of Guerrero Jr.’s potential contract demands, let’s examine recent contract extensions signed by other top MLB players:
| Player | Team | Years | Total Value | AAV |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Juan Soto | Mets | 15 | $765 million | $51 million |
| Shohei Ohtani | Dodgers | 10 | $700 million | $70 million |
| Mike Trout | Angels | 12 | $426.5 million | $35.5 million |
| Mookie Betts | Dodgers | 12 | $365 million | $30.4 million |
| Aaron Judge | Yankees | 9 | $360 million | $40 million |
| Manny Machado | Padres | 11 | $350 million | $31.8 million |
| Francisco Lindor | Mets | 10 | $341 million | $34.1 million |
| Fernando Tatis Jr. | Padres | 14 | $340 million | $24.3 million |
| Bryce Harper | Phillies | 13 | $330 million | $25.4 million |
It’s crucial to acknowledge that Ohtani’s contract, while initially reported as $700 million, is valued at $437.8 million by the MLBPA due to deferred payments . This distinction highlights the complexities of MLB contracts and how deferred payments can significantly impact a contract’s true value.
These recent contracts, particularly Soto’s record-breaking deal, have reset the market for elite players. Guerrero Jr.’s potential contract could further redefine these norms. It might exceed Miguel Cabrera’s $292 million extension with the Tigers. This extension currently stands as the largest contract ever given to a first baseman .
The Blue Jays’ Payroll and Willingness to Spend
The Toronto Blue Jays currently have the fifth-highest payroll in MLB, standing at $239,162,379 . This indicates a clear willingness to invest in top talent. However, they have also been cautious about committing to long-term contracts. Their most substantial contract to date is George Springer’s six-year, $150 million deal .
Despite this historical reluctance towards lengthy contracts, the Blue Jays are undeniably in a “win-now” mode . They have a young, dynamic core of players. They made significant additions to their roster. These include the signings of Anthony Santander and Max Scherzer, as well as acquiring Andres Gimenez . These moves signal their intent to compete for a World Series title, and securing Guerrero Jr. with a long-term extension would be a crucial step towards achieving that goal.
However, the Blue Jays have faced challenges in attracting top free agents, despite offering competitive salaries . This difficulty further emphasizes the importance of retaining their homegrown star, Guerrero Jr. Extending him would bolster their on-field performance. It would also send a strong message to other players and fans. This message is that the Blue Jays are serious contenders.
Furthermore, extending Guerrero Jr. could have a significant impact on the Blue Jays’ payroll and their ability to maintain a competitive roster. As one Reddit user pointed out, extending Guerrero Jr. could push their payroll high. Signing another top player, like Pete Alonso or Alex Bregman, could further increase it to among the highest in baseball. This would make them a virtual lock for a playoff spot.
Factors That Could Influence the Negotiations
| Factor | Explanation/Impact |
|---|---|
| Guerrero Jr.’s performance in 2025 | Another strong season, especially an MVP-caliber performance, will undoubtedly increase his market value and strengthen his negotiating position. |
| The Blue Jays’ financial situation | The team’s willingness to spend will be influenced by their confidence. They need to believe in their ability to contend for a World Series title. A strong start to the 2025 season could encourage them to offer a more lucrative contract. |
| The overall market for top players | The constantly evolving market for elite players will play a significant role. Recent record-breaking contracts, like Soto’s, have set a new standard and will likely influence Guerrero Jr.’s expectations. |
| Bo Bichette’s future with the team | Bichette, another key player for the Blue Jays, is also approaching free agency. Guerrero Jr.’s decision could affect whether Bichette decides to stay in Toronto. Bichette has expressed a desire to win alongside Guerrero Jr.. |
These factors create a complex web of considerations for both Guerrero Jr. and the Blue Jays. Each side must carefully weigh the potential risks and rewards before reaching an agreement.
Risks and Rewards of an Extension vs. Free Agency
Both the Blue Jays and Guerrero Jr. face inherent risks and potential rewards in deciding whether to pursue an extension now or wait for free agency:
Risks for the Blue Jays:
- Injury or decline in performance: A long-term, high-value contract carries the risk of Guerrero Jr. suffering a significant injury or experiencing a decline in performance. This situation would leave the Blue Jays with a substantial financial burden. They might have a player who may not live up to expectations.
Rewards for the Blue Jays:
- Securing a franchise cornerstone: Signing Guerrero Jr. to an extension ensures they retain a generational talent. He is also a fan favorite who can lead the team to success for years to come.
- Increased appeal to other players: Demonstrating a commitment to building a winning team by extending Guerrero Jr. could make the Blue Jays a more attractive destination for other free agents in the future.
Risks for Guerrero Jr.:
- Leaving money on the table: If Guerrero Jr. signs an extension now and has an exceptional 2025 season, he might miss out on an even larger contract. This could happen in free agency.
Rewards for Guerrero Jr.:
- Financial security: An extension now guarantees Guerrero Jr. hundreds of millions of dollars, providing long-term financial stability.
- Building a legacy in Toronto: Signing an extension allows Guerrero Jr. to continue playing in a city where he is beloved by fans. He has the opportunity to become a franchise legend.
Potential Terms of a Guerrero Jr. Extension
Considering Guerrero Jr.’s market value, recent contracts for comparable players, and the Blue Jays’ circumstances, here’s a potential range of terms for a contract extension:
- Length of contract: 10-12 years
- Total value: $400-$500 million
- Average annual salary: $40-$50 million
It’s important to remember that this is just a potential range. The actual terms will depend on the factors discussed above and the outcome of negotiations. There is a reported gap between Guerrero Jr.’s expectations and the Blue Jays’ previous offer of $340 million. It is likely that the final contract will be closer to the higher end of this range.
Conclusion
The Blue Jays face a pivotal decision this off-season. Extending Vladimir Guerrero Jr. would secure a cornerstone of their franchise and solidify their position as World Series contenders. However, it would require a significant financial commitment and carry inherent risks. Letting him walk in free agency could jeopardize their chances of sustained success. It could also potentially alienate a fanbase eager for a championship.
Retaining Guerrero Jr. is crucial for the team’s on-field performance. It is also vital for maintaining fan interest and attendance, especially after the recent stadium renovations . His presence has a significant impact on the Blue Jays’ brand and their ability to attract fans and generate revenue.
Ultimately, the decision will likely come down to whether the Blue Jays are willing to meet Guerrero Jr.’s demands and make him one of the highest-paid players in MLB history. The outcome of these negotiations could have a ripple effect throughout the league. It could potentially influence future contracts for other young stars. It may also shape the landscape of MLB free agency. Sources and related content
ScortonBoy17.ca 
Leave a comment