The Toronto Maple Leafs organization currently stands at a precipice that demands an exhaustive evaluation of its executive leadership. The 2025-26 National Hockey League season is progressing past the midway point. The “New Direction” initiated by Maple Leaf Sports & Entertainment (MLSE) President and CEO Keith Pelley is under critical scrutiny. General Manager Brad Treliving, the primary architect of the current roster, is under an intense microscope. The team’s competitive profile has shifted from a perennial regular-season powerhouse to a fringe playoff contender. It is now struggling with structural imbalances and asset depletion.¹ This report examines the systemic failures of the Treliving tenure. It addresses the strategic misalignment between roster construction and modern tactical requirements. Additionally, it discusses the necessity of identifying a successor. This successor must be able to navigate the complex salary cap landscape of the 2026 Collective Bargaining Agreement era.

The Statistical Regression and Tactical Misalignment

The fundamental argument for a change in leadership is rooted in the team’s performance metrics. These metrics have measurably declined across multiple seasons. Under the previous regime, the Maple Leafs consistently ranked among the top six in the NHL for expected goal share. They were also among the top for offensive generation.³ The team transitioned to Brad Treliving’s vision in the 2024 offseason. This was marked by the hiring of head coach Craig Berube. This change aimed to instill a “playoff-style” identity. The focus was on prioritizing size, physicality, and defensive structure.⁴ However, the reality of the 2025-26 campaign shows a team that has become notably slower. The team has become heavier. It is less capable of controlling the pace of play.³

As of late January 2026, the Maple Leafs are in seventh place in the Atlantic Division. They have a record of 24-19-9. The team has accumulated 57 points through 52 games.⁶ This represents a significant downturn from the 108-point, division-leading performance of the previous year.⁷ The team’s goal differential of -6 is stark. It indicates a roster that is neither scoring at its historical elite rate nor preventing goals effectively enough to compensate.⁶

Comparison of Team Performance Indicators (2024-2026)

Metric	2024-25 Season (Berube Year 1)	2025-26 Season (Jan Update)	Trend Analysis
Points Percentage	.659	.570	Significant Regression 7
Goals Against Average	2.79	3.38	Defensive Instability 4
Power Play Success	24.8% (9th)	20.8% (14th)	Tactical Stagnation 4
Save Percentage (Team)	.926 (1st)	.880 (30th)	Goaltending Collapse 3
Division Standing	1st (Atlantic)	7th (Atlantic)	Competitive Decline 6

The data suggests that the team’s high-octane offense was systematically sacrificed. This offense scored 298 goals under Sheldon Keefe. It was sacrificed for a dump-and-chase brand of hockey. This strategy has failed to yield the promised defensive dividends.⁴ While the penalty kill has remained a relative strength, ranking third in the NHL at 84.5% as of January 2026, the team’s overall five-on-five play has deteriorated significantly. The team is now outshot and outchanced on a nightly basis.⁸

Asset Management and the Cost of “Truculence”

The second pillar of the case for Treliving’s removal is the catastrophic depletion of the organization’s asset cupboard. The General Manager aimed to force a “win-now” window by surrendering a wealth of future capital. However, the veteran pieces acquired have largely underperformed their acquisition costs. The worst mismanagement happened during the 2025 trade deadline. Treliving moved two first-round picks and the team’s top two prospects for Scott Laughton and Brandon Carlo.²

The acquisition of Brandon Carlo from the Boston Bruins has emerged as a franchise-altering mistake. To secure the 6’5″ defenseman, Toronto surrendered Fraser Minten. He was a 20-year-old center projected as a foundational piece of the team’s middle-six. They also traded a 2026 first-round pick.¹⁰ Carlo’s tenure in Toronto has been defined by injury and a perceived lack of mobility. Since his arrival, he has been described as playing “like he’s 5’6″.” He fails to provide the physical presence Treliving coveted. Additionally, he struggles to transport the puck out of the defensive zone.⁵ Simultaneously, Minten is excelling in Boston. He is currently serving as an every-night third-line center. This is a role the Maple Leafs have desperately failed to fill internally.¹⁰

Evaluation of Major Trade Costs and Current Returns

Acquired Player	Cost to Toronto	Performance Summary (Jan 2026)	Strategic Impact
Brandon Carlo	Fraser Minten + 2026 1st	4 assists in 18 games; foot surgery in Dec 2	Negative; lost top prospect and 1st rounder
Scott Laughton	Nikita Grebenkin + 2027 1st	8 goals, 2 assists in 33 games 13	Mixed; strong PK but high asset cost 9
Joel Edmundson	3rd and 5th Round Picks	Depth defender; provided minimal impact 10	Neutral; overpaid for depth
Nicolas Roy	Mitch Marner (Trade)	28-year-old defensive center; effective in 3 zones 2	Positive; only high-value acquisition 9

The trade for Scott Laughton involved surrendering Nikita Grebenkin. He is a rugged young winger with high offensive upside. The trade also included a top-10 protected 2027 first-round pick.¹⁴ Laughton has been a serviceable penalty killer. He is respected in the locker room. However, his production—only 10 points in 33 games—hardly justifies the loss of a first-round selection and a blue-chip prospect.¹⁰ This trend of overpaying for “sandpaper” and grit has reduced skill and future flexibility. Consequently, the organization has only one draft pick in the first four rounds of the 2026 NHL Draft.²

*Let me state this. I love Scott Laughton. I wanted him on the Maple Leafs since I saw him play for the Oshawa Generals in junior. The price to get him was high, but I would still make that trade today.*

The Mitch Marner Exit and Superstar Attrition

Treliving’s tenure is also defined by his inability to manage the contract situation of star winger Mitch Marner. Treliving allowed the relationship to reach a point of no return. As a result, he lost significant leverage. He eventually traded Marner to the Vegas Golden Knights for an underwhelming return centred on Nicolas Roy. 1 While Roy has performed admirably as a right-handed center, the team faces a substantial challenge. The void left by Marner’s 100-point production in the top six remains. This gap has not been adequately addressed through free agency or internal development.¹

This trend mirrors Treliving’s history in Calgary. He oversaw the exits of Johnny Gaudreau, Matthew Tkachuk, and Adam Fox. These are talents he was either unable to sign or forced to trade under duress.¹⁵ The recurring theme is a failure to secure superstars to long-term extensions early. Superstars often reach the final year of their contracts without extensions. This issue has migrated from Calgary to Toronto.¹ In contrast, Treliving did successfully extend Auston Matthews. He also extended William Nylander early in his tenure. However, these are viewed as “slam-dunk” decisions. They required less tactical negotiation than the Marner situation.¹

The whole Marner situation should have been resolved before his no-trade clause came into effect on July 1, 2023. However, Team President Brendan Shanahan did not allow Brad to trade him. This ultimately led to Brendan being relieved of his duties in May 2025.

Contractual Stagnation and Misallocation of Funds

The financial management under Treliving has drawn sharp criticism, particularly regarding the extension of Max Domi. After a productive initial one-year deal, Treliving signed Domi to a four-year, $15 million contract.¹⁰ Critics argue this was a “disaster” two years in. Domi’s defensive deficiencies have been exposed under Berube’s system. His offensive output is significantly below the required value for his cap hit. He has scored only 11 goals in nearly 100 games since the extension.¹⁰

Player	Contract Status	Cap Hit	Performance Analysis
Max Domi	Signed through 2028	$3.75M	25 points in 50 games; -17 rating 13
Bobby McMann	Pending UFA (2026)	Seeking $5M	16 goals in 50 games; physical presence 17
John Tavares	Pending UFA (2026)	Negotiating	4.4M projected; still effective leader 18
Scott Laughton	Signed through 2026	$1.5M (50% Ret.)	Veteran PK specialist 11

The organization now faces a “position of strength” regarding cap space for the summer of 2026. An estimated $24 million to $25 million is available.¹⁸ However, the looming 2026 CBA changes introduce a playoff salary cap. These changes require a General Manager who can build a deep, 20-man roster. This roster must remain cap-compliant through the postseason.²⁰ Treliving often overvalues veteran depth. This suggests he may not be the optimal candidate. He may struggle to handle this transformative financial window.¹⁰

The Keith Pelley Mandate: A Search for “The Courage to Change”

Keith Pelley, as the new President and CEO of MLSE, is the primary catalyst for a managerial shift. Since assuming his role in April 2024, Pelley has introduced a results-oriented philosophy. This approach differs markedly from the patience-heavy “Shanaplan” era.²¹ Pelley’s dismissal of Brendan Shanahan in May 2025 sent a clear signal. The organization’s standard is no longer merely making the playoffs. They now aim for winning championships.²²

Pelley has consistently articulated a “win-now” timeline, deferring to Treliving on personnel matters while “watching hawkishly” from above.²² In his major address, “The Courage to Change in the Pursuit of Championships,” Pelley emphasized a management style. It was meant for the Maple Leafs. He suggested adopting a “merciless approach to losing.” This is similar to the strategy used by elite European football clubs such as Real Madrid.²² As the team “bottom-feeds” in the Eastern Conference standings, the sentiment is that Treliving’s time is running out. If the team continues its freefall into the Olympic break, Pelley is expected to act. He will prioritize hiring a General Manager. The new manager should align with a more modern, analytically rigorous, and asset-conscious approach.²

Potential Successors: A Strategic Shortlist

Identifying the correct replacement for Brad Treliving requires a candidate who can balance the immediate pressure of the Toronto market. They must also address the long-term need for asset recovery and cap efficiency. The following candidates represent the most viable paths for the organization in 2026.

Brandon Pridham: The Internal Cap Strategist

Brandon Pridham is widely considered the leading internal candidate. Pridham serves as the Assistant General Manager. He is the team’s resident CBA and cap specialist. Pridham has been a constant in the organization since 2014.²⁵ He is credited with the “cap gymnastics.” This maneuver allowed the team to remain competitive during the flat-cap era of the COVID-19 pandemic.²⁵

An appointment of Pridham would represent a shift toward “Moneyball” principles. This involves roster construction driven by efficiency, matchups, and situational effectiveness. It focuses more on these aspects rather than reputation or optics.²⁶ Advocates for Pridham argue that he has seen “every possible mistake a team could make” over the last decade. They believe he is best positioned to extract maximum value from the team’s remaining resources.²⁶ Given the upcoming 2026 playoff cap rules, Pridham’s expertise in CBA nuance would be a critical institutional advantage.²⁶

Mathieu Darche: The Championship Pedigree

Mathieu Darche, currently the New York Islanders’ General Manager, is the premier external candidate. Darche’s reputation was forged as the Tampa Bay Lightning’s Assistant GM. He served under Julien BriseBois. The team achieved back-to-back Stanley Cup wins in 2020 and 2021.²⁸ Darche is praised for his ability to maintain a championship-grade roster. He does this despite losing star players to cap constraints. This skill set is directly applicable to the Maple Leafs’ “Core Four” dilemma.²⁸

In his first year with the Islanders, Darche demonstrated a “flexible and focused” approach. He quickly identified that his team was better than its record suggested. He made bold moves, such as moving Noah Dobson at the draft, to adjust the culture.³⁰ Darche has professional playing experience with 250 NHL games. He also holds a business degree in marketing and international business. This combination makes him a “sharp, knowledgeable, and hungry” executive. He understands both the locker room and the boardroom.³¹

He just got to Long Island, and he is not going anywhere unless its a job promotion.

Mark Yannetti: The Scouting Visionary

The Maple Leafs may prioritize replenishing their prospect pool. If so, Mark Yannetti of the Los Angeles Kings is a “master class in hockey evolution”.³³ As the Kings’ Director of Amateur Scouting, Yannetti is a key member of their front office “inner circle.” He has a deep understanding of the full arc of a roster. This ranges from championship contention through rebuilding.³³ He can identify and develop young talent. This ability would address the organization’s current deficit of blue-chip prospects. Players like Fraser Minten and Nikita Grebenkin, who were traded away under the current administration, are examples.¹⁰

Additional Candidates and Evaluative Profiles

Candidate	Current Role	Notable Qualifications	Strategic Fit for Toronto
Eric Tulsky	GM (Hurricanes)	Leading analytics voice; sustainable success 34	High (Analytical Rigor)
Jason Botterill	GM (Kraken)	Former Sabres GM; cap and roster depth specialist 34	Medium (Experienced)
George McPhee	Pres (Knights)	Architect of Vegas’ aggressive roster build 35	Medium (Aggressive)
Mathieu Darche	GM (Islanders)	Tampa Bay pedigree; cap-efficient success 28	High (Best Overall)
Brandon Pridham	AGM (Leafs)	Elite cap strategist; internal knowledge 25	High (Smooth Transition)

The 2026 CBA: A New Paradigm for Roster Construction

The most compelling reason for an immediate managerial transition is the introduction of the playoff salary cap in 2026. This change fundamentally alters the landscape of the “post-deadline” roster. Teams can no longer use LTIR to exceed the cap during the playoffs.²⁰ Every addition at the trade deadline must now remain cap-compliant throughout the postseason.²⁰

This “evened-out” system rewards “clever, sustainable approaches” rather than “crafty loophole tricks”.²⁰ The Maple Leafs currently have over $79 million committed to just 16 players for the 2026-27 season. This situation has significantly narrowed the margin for error.²⁷ The next General Manager must identify “inexpensive depth” that can contribute in high-stakes moments. They should avoid surrendering first-round picks for fourth-line centers and bottom-pair defensemen.²

Roster Requirements Under 2026 CBA Rules

• Playoff Cap Compliance: Teams must provide a 20-man roster that stays under the cap ceiling for every playoff game.²⁰
• Retention Restrictions: Players must be with a club for 75 days before the team can retain salary in a trade. This rule makes “double retention” blockbuster deals nearly impossible.²⁷
• LTIR Limitations: Regular-season LTIR relief is now limited to the average league salary unless approved by the NHL and NHLPA.²⁰

This regulatory shift requires a General Manager with the “conviction” to build through efficiency rather than optics.²⁶ The current administration’s reliance on “grit” and “identity” players is a frequent issue. It has come at the expense of the cap flexibility needed to navigate these new constraints.

Conclusion and Strategic Recommendation

The Toronto Maple Leafs are at a crossroads that require more than a tactical adjustment. They need a structural reset of their hockey operations department. Brad Treliving’s tenure has shown a philosophical mismatch. He attempted to mould a high-skill, high-speed roster into a heavy, grinding unit. However, the modern NHL has largely moved past this style. The statistical regression in 2025-26 has created an environment of instability. The depletion of the organization’s prospect pool and the mismanagement of the Mitch Marner exit have further compounded the problem. This environment threatens to waste the prime years of Auston Matthews and William Nylander.¹

Keith Pelley mandates a “championship or bust” performance. The 2026 offseason provides looming financial opportunities. The organization needs a leader who can leverage the $25 million in available cap space with precision. This requires analytical foresight.¹⁸ Brandon Pridham offers the most immediate path to cap stability. He ensures internal continuity. Mathieu Darche provides a proven model of championship success from a high-pressure market.²⁶

The time for “incrementalism” has passed. The Maple Leafs need to embrace change to fulfill their destiny as the “greatest hockey team in the world.” They must have the “courage to change” at the top.²² Replacing Brad Treliving is not merely about assigning blame for a slow start to the 2025-26 season. It is about making sure the organization has the intellectual capital it needs. Strategic capital is also necessary to win in the most competitive era of NHL history.

It’s Brandon Pridham’s time to shine!

Works cited

1. Treliving faces unprecedented pressure in most critical season as Leafs GM – Editor In Leaf, accessed January 27, 2026, https://editorinleaf.com/treliving-faces-unprecedented-pressure-in-most-critical-season-as-leafs-gm
2. Brad Treliving’s trade history should be concerning for struggling …, accessed January 27, 2026, https://theleafsnation.com/news/brad-treliving-trade-history-concerning-struggling-toronto-maple-leafs
3. The 2025 Toronto Maple Leafs: A Post-Mortem – Reddit, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/leafs/comments/1p03lmb/the_2025_toronto_maple_leafs_a_postmortem/
4. Toronto Maple Leafs 2025–26 Season: Realistic Expectations – 6IX ON ICE, accessed January 27, 2026, https://6ixonice.com/2025/08/30/toronto-maple-leafs-2025-26-season-realistic-expectations/
5. Should the spotlight be on Brad Treliving more for Leafs’ current struggles? – Daily Faceoff, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.dailyfaceoff.com/news/brad-treliving-toronto-maple-leafs-current-struggles-blame-gm
6. 2025–26 Toronto Maple Leafs season – Wikipedia, accessed January 27, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025%E2%80%9326_Toronto_Maple_Leafs_season
7. What to make of the Maple Leafs 50 games into the post-Marner era | theScore.com, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.thescore.com/nhl/news/3460962/what-to-make-of-the-maple-leafs-50-games-into-the-post-marner-era
8. 2025-26 Toronto Maple Leafs Roster and Statistics – Hockey-Reference.com, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.hockey-reference.com/teams/TOR/2026.html
9. How Brad Treliving helped transform a key weakness for the Maple Leafs – Hockey Patrol, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.hockeypatrol.com/nhl-team/toronto-maple-leafs/how-brad-treliving-helped-transform-a-key-weakness-for-the-maple-leafs
10. Grading Brad Treliving’s major moves as Toronto Maple Leafs GM …, accessed January 27, 2026, https://6ixonice.com/2025/11/29/grading-brad-trelivings-major-moves-as-toronto-maple-leafs-gm/
11. Toronto Maple Leafs’ Trade Deadline Acquisitions Are Key Puzzle Pieces In 2025-26, accessed January 27, 2026, https://thehockeynews.com/news/latest-news/toronto-maple-leafs-trade-deadline-acquisitions-are-key-puzzle-pieces-in-2025-26
12. 4 Maple Leafs Looking for a Better Result in 2026 – The Hockey Writers, accessed January 27, 2026, https://thehockeywriters.com/4-maple-leafs-looking-for-better-result-2026/
13. Toronto Maple Leafs News, Scores and Stats 2025-26 – CBS Sports, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.cbssports.com/nhl/teams/TOR/toronto-maple-leafs/
14. Maple Leafs land Scott Laughton from Flyers, Brandon Carlo from Bruins in deadline deals, accessed January 27, 2026, https://ca.news.yahoo.com/maple-leafs-acquire-centre-scott-182610683.html
15. Career to date: who is Brad Treliving? – Pension Plan Puppets, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.pensionplanpuppets.com/career-to-date-who-is-reported-leafs-gm-brad-treliving/
16. Brad Treliving was a bad hire. : r/torontomapleleafs – Reddit, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/torontomapleleafs/comments/1pntlk5/brad_treliving_was_a_bad_hire/
17. Two Leafs forwards are on Brad Treliving’s extension list right now – Hockey Patrol, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.hockeypatrol.com/nhl-team/toronto-maple-leafs/two-leafs-forwards-are-on-brad-treliving-extension-list-right-now
18. Brad Treliving Holds $24 Million, Putting Maple Leafs in Position of Strength – Hockey Patrol, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.hockeypatrol.com/nhl-team/toronto-maple-leafs/brad-treliving-holds-24-million-putting-maple-leafs-in-position-of-strength
19. Make A Blockbuster Trade Or Save Cap Space For 2026 Off-Season? What Should The Maple Leafs Do? – The Hockey News, accessed January 27, 2026, https://thehockeynews.com/news/latest-news/make-a-blockbuster-trade-or-save-cap-space-for-2026-off-season-what-should-the-maple-leafs-do
20. The NHL playoff salary cap begins in 2026 and every contender is wondering which team will crack under the new rules first – Times of India, accessed January 27, 2026, https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/nhl/news/the-nhl-playoff-salary-cap-begins-in-2026-and-every-contender-is-wondering-which-team-will-crack-under-the-new-rules-first/articleshow/123688788.cms
21. KEITH PELLEY President & CEO of MLSE – Board of Directors, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.mlsefoundation.org/board-of-directors/keith-pelley
22. The institutional weight of the next Leafs era lies squarely with Keith Pelley, accessed January 27, 2026, https://theleafsnation.com/news/institutional-weight-next-toronto-maple-leafs-era-squarely-keith-pelley
23. Report: Brad Treliving Staying On As Maple Leafs GM After MLSE …, accessed January 27, 2026, https://thehockeynews.com/nhl/toronto-maple-leafs/latest-news/report-brad-treliving-staying-on-as-maple-leafs-gm-after-mlse-moves-on-from-team-president-brendan-shanahan
24. The Courage to Change in The Pursuit of Championships: Keith Pelley, President & CEO of Maple Leaf Sports & Entertainment – Empire Club of Canada, accessed January 27, 2026, https://empireclubofcanada.com/event/the-courage-to-change-in-the-pursuit-of-championships-keith-pelley-president-ceo-of-maple-leaf-sports-entertainment/
25. Brandon Pridham promoted to Assistant General Manager of the Toronto Maple Leafs, accessed January 27, 2026, https://mapleleafshotstove.com/2018/05/23/brandon-pridham-promoted-to-assistant-general-manager-of-the-toronto-maple-leafs/
26. Brandon Pridham May Be the Maple Leafs’ Untapped Advantage – The Hockey Writers, accessed January 27, 2026, https://thehockeywriters.com/brandon-pridham-may-be-the-maple-leafs-untapped-advantage/
27. Immediate CBA impacts and preparing for the 2026 Maple Leafs …, accessed January 27, 2026, https://theleafsnation.com/news/immediate-cba-impacts-preparing-2026-toronto-maple-leafs-salary-cap-situation-leaflets
28. Eight candidates to replace Kyle Dubas as Toronto Maple Leafs GM – Daily Faceoff, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.dailyfaceoff.com/news/nine-candidates-to-replace-kyle-dubas-as-toronto-maple-leafs-gm
29. Darche focused on making Islanders ‘winning organization’ | NHL.com, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.nhl.com/news/mathieu-darche-focused-on-making-new-york-islanders-a-winning-organization
30. NY Islanders GM Mathieu Darche’s flexible and focused approach has franchise rolling, accessed January 27, 2026, https://eyesonisles.com/ny-islanders-gm-mathieu-darche-s-flexible-and-focused-approach-has-franchise-rolling-01kebc4f504b
31. 10 candidates to replace Lou Lamoriello as Islanders GM – Daily Faceoff, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.dailyfaceoff.com/news/10-gm-candidates-replace-lou-lamoriello-new-york-lslanders-holland-bergevin-pridham
32. Darche making most of 2nd career, hired as Islanders general manager | NHL.com, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.nhl.com/news/islanders-general-manager-mathieu-darche-making-most-of-2nd-career-as-executive
33. Potential GM Candidates for LA Kings, accessed January 27, 2026, https://mayorsmanor.com/2025/05/potential-gm-candidates-for-la-kings/
34. Who are the Available GM Candidates with “Experience”? : r/leafs – Reddit, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/leafs/comments/13mb1zx/who_are_the_available_gm_candidates_with/
35. Who should replace Brad Treliving as GM if he’s fired? : r/torontomapleleafs – Reddit, accessed January 27, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/torontomapleleafs/comments/1p9u63k/who_should_replace_brad_treliving_as_gm_if_hes/
36. Keith Pelley on a possible shift in the Leafs’ management style without Brendan Shanahan: “The only fundamental difference — from a hockey perspective, this will be Brad Treliving’s team”, accessed January 27, 2026, https://mapleleafshotstove.com/2025/05/27/keith-pelley-on-the-possible-shift-in-the-leafs-managerial-style-without-brendan-shanahan/