The Brooklin Lacrosse Club’s historical trajectory is unique. It serves as a case study in preserving amateur box lacrosse. It also highlights the professionalization of the sport within the Canadian landscape. Founded in 1961, the organization has roots that extend back to the late 1920s. It has functioned as a central repository for the cultural and athletic identity of Brooklin. This also includes the surrounding Town of Whitby.¹ Over nearly six decades, the club has participated in Senior “A” competition. It navigated significant shifts in regional demographics, athletic infrastructure, and societal norms. These shifts culminated in the 2019 transition from its long-standing “Redmen” moniker to the Brooklin Lacrosse Club.¹ This report delves into the club’s historical origins. It covers its dominant championship eras, including the unparalleled dynasty of the 1980s. The report also examines the club’s institutional role in the Major Series Lacrosse (MSL) ecosystem and its recent structural rebranding.

The Formative Era: Field Origins and the Transition to Senior A (1928–1960)

The Brooklin Lacrosse Club was formalized in 1961. This event marked the culmination of over thirty years of grassroots development in the Durham Region. The sport of lacrosse in Brooklin began in 1928. At that time, the game was predominantly played in its traditional field format.³ Jack MacDuff and Bill Scott spearheaded the local movement. They catalyzed a community-wide interest in what was then, and remains, Canada’s national summer sport.³ Foundational players, such as Art and Jim Patterson, made significant contributions in this early period. They helped to establish Brooklin as a competitive node within the Ontario lacrosse circuit.³

By 1934, the popularity of field lacrosse waned. People preferred the more compact and faster-paced box lacrosse format. Brooklin successfully transitioned its programs to the indoor game.³ This shift was not merely tactical but logistical, allowing for more consistent scheduling and the utilization of local arenas. During this developmental phase, Brooklin fielded an intermediate team. They competed within the Ontario Lacrosse Association (OLA). The team secured multiple intermediate and Senior “B” championships.³ These successes provided the institutional confidence needed. They also established a financial foundation. With these in place, Brooklin applied for a Senior “A” franchise. It was granted in 1961.¹

Institutional Evolution and the Hillcrest and Merchant Identities (1961–1966)

The entry into the senior series in 1961 marked the beginning of a new era for Brooklin athletics. For its first four seasons, the team competed as the Brooklin Hillcrests. This was a period characterized by rapid maturation. They played in a league populated by larger municipal centers.¹ Despite the relatively small population base of Brooklin at the time, the team proved immediately competitive. In their inaugural senior season of 1961, the Hillcrests finished fourth in the league. This was a significant achievement for a debutant organization.³

The team’s upward trajectory accelerated quickly. By 1963, just three years into their Senior “A” tenure, the club secured its first Ontario Senior A championship.³ This provincial dominance continued through 1964 and 1965, with the team rebranding as the Brooklin Merchants in 1965.¹ During this phase, Brooklin reached the national finals for the Mann Cup in both 1964 and 1965. However, they were unable to secure the trophy in these initial attempts.³ The move to the Merchants name was short-lived. The organization adopted the “Redmen” moniker in 1966. This identity would be maintained for over half a century.¹

Table 1: Chronological Development of Senior Team Identities

Era	Primary Designation	Competition Level	Historical Significance
1928–1933	Brooklin Lacrosse	Field Lacrosse	Inauguration by Jack MacDuff and Bill Scott.
1934–1960	Brooklin Intermediate	OLA Intermediate/Senior B	Transition from field to box format.
1961–1964	Brooklin Hillcrests	OLA Senior A	Entry into the Senior series; 1963 Ontario Title.
1965	Brooklin Merchants	OLA Senior A	Continued provincial dominance.
1966–2018	Brooklin Redmen	Major Series Lacrosse	Established the 1980s dynasty; 7 Mann Cups.
2019–Present	Brooklin Lacrosse Club	Major Series Lacrosse	Rebranding focused on inclusivity and modernity.

¹

The First Championship Cycle: 1968 and 1969 Mann Cup Triumphs

The transition to the Redmen identity coincided with the most successful period in the club’s early senior history. In 1968, the organization achieved its primary objective: the Mann Cup Canadian Championship. The Redmen secured the title by defeating the Nanaimo Luckies in a four-game sweep. This victory marked the first time the national trophy would reside in Brooklin.¹ This victory validated the club’s community-funded and volunteer-operated model. It demonstrated that a locally focused organization could compete with and defeat the established powers of Western Canada.²

The success of the 1968 squad was not an isolated event. In 1969, the Redmen successfully defended their national title, defeating the New Westminster Blues four games to one.¹ This consecutive championship solidified Brooklin’s reputation as the premier franchise in Ontario. It established a benchmark for subsequent generations of players. The 1968 team was eventually honoured with induction into the Whitby Sports Hall of Fame in 1999. This induction emphasizes its enduring importance to the regional sporting heritage.⁵

Regional Shifts and the Oshawa Interregnum (1970–1984)

The 1970s represented a period of geographic and competitive transition for Brooklin. The Redmen’s home games were moved to Oshawa for part of this decade. This move created a temporary void in the immediate Whitby-Brooklin corridor.⁶ During this time, other local organizations took action to sustain the area’s lacrosse culture. Groups like the Whitby B&R Transporters played a crucial role in this effort.⁶ The B&R Transporters achieved significant success at the Junior “B” level, winning national titles in 1970 and 1974.⁵

This era was critical for the long-term sustainability of the senior club. The Whitby Consolidated Builders formed at the Junior “A” level in 1975. They were later rebranded as the Whitby Warriors in 1984. This formation ensured a consistent pipeline of elite youth talent.⁷ The junior and senior programs in Durham Region worked together synergistically. This cooperation became a foundational element of the club’s strategy. The vast majority of players were recruited from the local region.⁹

The Peter Vipond Era and the 1985–1991 Dynasty

The most prolific era in the history of the Brooklin Lacrosse Club began in 1985. It was characterized by an unprecedented period of dominance in Major Series Lacrosse. This era was defined by the leadership of Head Coach Peter Vipond and General Managers Mike Gray and Bob Duignan.¹⁰ Vipond had previously led the Whitby Warriors to a Minto Cup in 1984. He brought a sophisticated tactical approach to the senior game. His approach emphasized a “run and gun” transition offense. It was supported by a physically imposing defense.¹²

The 1985 Mann Cup: The Historic Comeback

The dynasty was inaugurated with what is widely considered the greatest comeback in the history of the Mann Cup. Facing the New Westminster Salmonbellies on the West Coast, the Redmen lost the first three games. This situation placed them on the brink of elimination.¹⁰ Brooklin won four consecutive games. This performance has never been replicated in a Mann Cup final. They secured the national title.¹⁰

Table 2: 1985 Mann Cup Final Series Breakdown

Game	Score	Winner	Key Outcome
Game 1	7–5	New Westminster	Brooklin trails 1-0.
Game 2	9–8	New Westminster	Brooklin trails 2-0.
Game 3	7–6	New Westminster	Brooklin trails 3-0.
Game 4	7–6	Brooklin	First win of the comeback.
Game 5	7–5	Brooklin	Series momentum shifts.
Game 6	9–5	Brooklin	Series tied 3-3.
Game 7	6–5	Brooklin	Brooklin wins the Mann Cup.

¹³

Goaltender Wayne Colley was the series MVP and received the Mike Kelly Award. His performance in the final four games was instrumental in staving off the Salmonbellies’ potent offense.¹⁰ This victory established the psychological resilience that would characterize the team for the next seven years.

The 84-Game Winning Streak and Undefeated Seasons

Following the 1985 title, the Redmen entered a phase of statistical anomaly. Between 1986 and 1989, the organization achieved a world-record winning streak of 84 consecutive games.¹⁰ The entire 1987 and 1988 seasons were included in this streak. During these seasons, the team did not suffer a single defeat in regular season or playoff competition.¹⁰

The 1988 squad is often cited by historians as the greatest Senior “A” team ever assembled.¹⁵ During that season, the Redmen finished with a total record of 28-2, including the Mann Cup finals.¹⁵ Their dominance was most evident in their goal differential; they outscored their opponents by an average of 12.8 goals per game.¹⁵ In 20 regular-season matches, the team produced 363 goals while allowing only 107.¹⁵ This parity between offensive production and defensive stability is unparalleled. It has not been matched in the modern era of the MSL.

Table 3: Dynasty Period Individual Award Dominance (1985–1991)

Award Type	Trophy Name	Years Won by Brooklin Players	Key Recipients
MSL Scoring Champion	Bucko MacDonald Trophy	1985–1991 (7 consecutive)	Gil Nieuwendyk, John Fusco, Derek Keenan, Gary Gait, Peter Parke
MSL Most Valuable Player	Jim Murphy Trophy	1985, 1987, 1988, 1989, 1990, 1991	John Jordan, Derek Keenan, Gary Gait, Peter Parke, John Fusco
Top Goaltender	Harry Lumley Award	1987, 1988, 1989, 1990	Wayne Colley, Ted Sawicki, Ken Passfield, Chris O’Reilly
Top Defensive Player	MSL Defensive Award	1987, 1989	Kevin Antram, Blaine Harrison

¹⁰

The roster during this period featured multiple future Hall of Fame inductees. These included the Gait brothers, Gary and Paul. They joined the team during the peak of the dynasty.¹⁰ Paul Gait earned recognition as the Mann Cup MVP during the 1990 championship run. Brooklin swept the Vancouver Burrards 4-0 in this series.¹

The Rivalry with the Peterborough Lakers

A defining feature of the Brooklin Lacrosse Club’s history is its long-standing and often volatile rivalry with the Peterborough Lakers. This competition is widely regarded as the premier rivalry in Canadian box lacrosse. It is fueled by geographic proximity and a shared history of elite-level competition.¹⁰

The rivalry reached a historic peak on August 26, 1989. On that day, Peterborough defeated Brooklin in the OLA playoff final. This victory officially ended the Redmen’s 84-game winning streak.¹⁰ The intensity of these matchups often necessitated heightened security. They were marked by significant physical play. Bench-clearing brawls, such as those seen in the 1989 playoff series, were common.¹⁷

In the contemporary era, the rivalry remains the primary draw for Major Series Lacrosse. The 2024 and 2025 seasons saw the two teams meet in high-stakes playoff series. In 2025, Brooklin forced a seventh game in the MSL semi-finals after trailing 2-0 and 3-2 in the series.¹⁶ The deciding game was an 8-7 overtime victory for Peterborough. This result highlighted the near-total parity that currently exists between the two organizations.¹⁶

Infrastructure and the Iroquois Park Sports Centre

Since the late 1970s, the primary home for Brooklin lacrosse has been the Iroquois Park Sports Centre (IPSC) in Whitby. The facility opened on January 8, 1977. It was designed by Raymond Moriyama. Since then, it has become Canada’s largest municipally owned and operated recreation complex.² The IPSC covers 250,000 square feet and is situated on 50 acres of parkland. It features six arenas. Recent renovations have added air conditioning and a professional-grade artificial turf surface.⁴

The venue serves as the logistical hub for the club’s three primary tiers. These tiers include the Senior “A” Brooklin Lacrosse Club, the Senior “B” Brooklin Merchants, and the Junior “A” Whitby Warriors.² This centralization of talent allows for a high degree of organizational continuity. The 2025 Presidents Cup, the national Senior “B” championship, was hosted at the IPSC. The Brooklin Merchants served as the host team.²²

The 2019 Rebranding: Transition to Brooklin Lacrosse Club

On April 20, 2019, the organization announced a comprehensive rebranding. They dropped the “Redmen” name in favour of the Brooklin Lacrosse Club.² This decision was part of a broader societal shift regarding the use of Indigenous-derived names and imagery in sports. The club’s official statement mentioned a growing sensitivity. This sensitivity concerns the use of Aboriginal people as logos and names. It was cited as the primary driver for the change.²

This transition was mirrored by other high-profile institutions during the same period. McGill University, for example, retired its “Redmen” name on April 12, 2019, following extensive consultations with Indigenous students and faculty.²³ The McGill name was historically a reference to the school’s colours rather than Indigenous people. However, the university acknowledged that the term had taken on pejorative connotations. These were no longer reflective of the community’s values.²³

For the Brooklin organization, the rebranding was a strategic effort to maintain its status as a community-inclusive organization. It also aimed to respect the Indigenous origins of the sport.²⁵ Rivals such as the Six Nations Chiefs commended the change publicly. They viewed the move as a respectful acknowledgment of the game’s heritage.²⁵

Contemporary Performance and Organizational Ecosystem (2024–2025)

As of the 2025 season, the Brooklin Lacrosse Club continues to operate as a premier franchise within Major Series Lacrosse. The team finished the 2025 regular season in third place with a 14-11 record. They were led by captain Connor Kearnan. Veteran goaltender Zach Higgins also provided leadership.²⁶

The Brooklin Merchants and the Pipeline

The organizational success is bolstered by the Brooklin Merchants, who compete in Ontario Series Lacrosse (OSL). In 2025, the Merchants finished first in their league with a 19-2 record. They secured their third provincial championship after a sweep of the Six Nations Rivermen.²² The Merchants play a critical role in developing players. They help players transition from the Junior “A” Whitby Warriors to the MSL.⁵

Table 4: 2025 Brooklin Merchants Statistical Leaders (Regular Season)

Statistic	Player	Total
Most Goals	Will MacLeod	38
Most Assists	Parker Pipher	50
Leading Scorer	Parker Pipher	61 (Points)
Top Goaltender	Deacan Knott & Lukas Coote	Lowest GAA (Team)

²¹

The Junior “A” Whitby Warriors remain one of the most successful youth programs in Canada. They have won the Minto Cup eight times. The team achieved recent victories in 2011, 2013, and 2022.⁷ This multi-tiered structure includes Minor, Junior “A”, Senior “B”, and Senior “A”. It ensures that Brooklin remains a destination for elite box lacrosse talent.

Hall of Fame Inductees and Individual Legacy

The club’s history is preserved in several ways. One way is through the induction of numerous players and builders into the Canadian and Ontario Lacrosse Halls of Fame. Peter Vipond was inducted as a builder in 2005. He remains the winningest coach in Senior lacrosse history with over 320 career victories. He has also won five Mann Cups.¹²

Individual players from the dynasty era, such as John Fusco and Tom Wreggitt, continue to hold records for career assists. John Fusco ranks 8th on the all-time playmakers list for box lacrosse. Tom Wreggitt ranks 9th on the same list.¹⁰ The 1985–1991 Brooklin Redmen team was collectively inducted into the Canadian Lacrosse Hall of Fame. This was in recognition of its sustained excellence. The team also had an 84-game winning streak.¹¹

Table 5: Brooklin Lacrosse Club Alumni Award – Most Dedicated

Year	Recipient	Significance
1993	Jason Richards	Early recipient of the formal alumni award.
1995	Greg Lepine	Back-to-back winner (1995-1996).
1998	Ken Millen	Recognized for multi-capacity service.
1999	Peter Lough	Key transition player toward the 2000 title.
2022	Josh Medeiros	Modern recipient representing OSL dedication.

²¹

Institutional Sustainability and Future Outlook

The Brooklin Lacrosse Club’s continued relevance is a product of its non-profit, volunteer-led organizational structure. Unlike many modern professional sports teams that rely on centralized ownership, Brooklin remains a community-operated entity. It is funded by local sponsors and gate receipts.¹ This model fosters a deep connection between the team and its fan base. Many fans have supported the organization across multiple decades and name changes.⁹

The club’s strategy for the 2025–2030 period includes leveraging its modernized home at the Iroquois Park Sports Centre. This will help increase its schedule of home games. The club also aims to continue hosting national events like the Presidents Cup.⁴ The organization maintains its affiliation with the Whitby Warriors and Brooklin Merchants. This strategy positions it well to remain a contender for the Mann Cup. The Mann Cup, donated by Sir Donald Mann in 1910, remains the most coveted prize in the sport.³¹

Conclusions

The Brooklin Lacrosse Club represents a vital component of the Canadian lacrosse ecosystem. The organization began as a small-town field lacrosse team in 1928. It evolved into a multi-generational powerhouse in Major Series Lacrosse. The club has consistently prioritized athletic excellence. It also focuses on community integration. The dynasty of 1985–1991 remains the high-water mark for the franchise. It established records for winning streaks and goal differentials. These achievements define the historical standards of the game.

The 2019 rebranding from the Redmen to the Brooklin Lacrosse Club shows the organization’s ability to evolve alongside societal expectations. It does this without sacrificing its competitive identity. The club has a robust developmental pipeline through the Whitby Warriors and Brooklin Merchants. It also boasts a world-class facility in the Iroquois Park Sports Centre. These elements effectively structure the club to sustain its legacy of elite amateur box lacrosse. The Brooklin Lacrosse Club is pursuing its eighth Mann Cup. It remains an essential guardian of the sport’s traditions in the Durham Region and beyond.

Works cited

1. History – Brooklin Lacrosse Club, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.brooklinlc.com/history
2. Brooklin Lacrosse Club – Wikipedia, accessed January 7, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooklin_Lacrosse_Club
3. brooklin redmen – Lacrosse Bible, accessed January 7, 2026, https://lacrossebible.ca/wp-content/uploads/1967-Brooklin-Redmen-SNR-A-000CV-compressed.pdf
4. Become A Partner – Brooklin Lacrosse Club, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.brooklinlc.com/become-a-partner
5. Sport of Lacrosse Well-Represented in Whitby Sports Hall of Fame, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.whitbysportshalloffame.com/sport-of-lacrosse-well-represented-in-whitby-sports-hall-of-fame/
6. Luther Vipond – Whitby Sports Hall of Fame, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.whitbysportshalloffame.com/inductees/luther-vipond/
7. Whitby Warriors Jr A – Canadian Lacrosse Magazine, accessed January 7, 2026, https://laxhall.com/2024/02/whitby-warriors-jr-a/
8. Whitby Warriors – Wikipedia, accessed January 7, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whitby_Warriors
9. News: Brooklin Alumni To Be Inducted Into Whitby Sports Hall Of Fame, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.brooklinlc.com/news/brooklin-alumni-to-be-inducted-into-wshof
10. About | Brooklin Redmen – WordPress.com, accessed January 7, 2026, https://brooklinredmen.wordpress.com/about/
11. Brooklin Redmen 1985 – 1991 – Canadian Lacrosse Hall of Fame, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.clhof.org/index.php/en/inductees/by-category/team/768-brooklin-redmen-1985-1991
12. Peter Vipond – Canadian Lacrosse Hall of Fame, accessed January 7, 2026, https://canlaxhall.org/peter-vipond/
13. Peter Vipond – Think Lacrosse, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.thinklacrosse.ca/2025/10/peter-vipond.html
14. New Westminster Salmonbellies – Think Lacrosse, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.thinklacrosse.ca/2025/10/new-westminster-salmonbellies.html
15. Who Are the Greatest Sr. A Lacrosse Teams of All Time?, accessed January 7, 2026, https://lacrosseculturedaily.com/2025/09/26/who-are-the-greatest-sr-a-lacrosse-teams-of-all-time/
16. News: PETERBOROUGH LAKERS BEAT BROOKLIN IN GAME 7; HEADS TO MSL FINALS, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.majorserieslacrosse.ca/news/peterborough-lakers-beat-brooklin-in-game-7-heads
17. Official Site – Peterborough Lakers Lacrosse, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.peterboroughlakers.ca/fan-zone
18. News: Overtime Loss by BLC Forces Game Seven – Brooklin Lacrosse Club, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.brooklinlc.com/news/overtime-loss-by-blc-forces-game-seven
19. Arena – Brooklin Lacrosse Club, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.brooklinlc.com/arena-and-home-game-info
20. Whitby, Ontario – Wikipedia, accessed January 7, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whitby,_Ontario
21. Brooklin Merchants – Wikipedia, accessed January 7, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooklin_Merchants
22. News (List) | Brooklin Merchants, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.brooklinmerchants.com/news
23. Decision about Redmen name – McGill University Athletics, accessed January 7, 2026, https://mcgillathletics.ca/sports/2019/4/12/decision-about-redmen-name.aspx
24. McGill drops Redmen team name – University Affairs, accessed January 7, 2026, https://universityaffairs.ca/news/mcgill-drops-redmen-team-name/
25. Brooklin Lacrosse Club drops “Redmen” name – Six Nations Chiefs, accessed January 7, 2026, http://sixnationschiefs.blogspot.com/2019/04/brooklin-lacrosse-club-drops-redmen-name.html
26. Brooklin LC Roster, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.brooklinlc.com/brooklin-lc-roster
27. Brooklin LC Schedule, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.brooklinlc.com/brooklin-lc-schedule
28. Merchants Roster – Brooklin Lacrosse Club, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.brooklinlc.com/osl-roster
29. Peter Vipond – OLHOF – Ontario Lacrosse Hall Of Fame, accessed January 7, 2026, https://ontariolacrossehalloffame.com/gallery-item/peter-vipond/
30. Alumni Award – Most Dedicated – Brooklin Lacrosse Club, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.brooklinlc.com/most-dedicated
31. History | CLA Mann Cup – Pointstreak Sites, accessed January 7, 2026, http://manncup.pointstreaksites.com/view/manncup/information/history
32. Mann Cup – Wikipedia, accessed January 7, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mann_Cup