I. Introduction: The World Series Hero, The Free Agent Problem
After a devastating 11-inning loss to the Los Angeles Dodgers in Game 7, the Toronto Blue Jays faced disappointment. Their clubhouse was a portrait of quiet despair.1 The 2025 season started with a franchise-altering contract extension in the spring. It stretched to the precipice of a championship in the fall. Abruptly and painfully, it was over.
The Dodgers celebrated their second consecutive title on Toronto’s home field 1. Meanwhile, the Blue Jays’ front office was forced to immediately pivot from the sting of defeat. They had to focus on the most critical offseason question in a decade. The reality is stark. Bo Bichette is the homegrown, two-time All-Star who defined the team’s competitive window. He is now a free agent.2
Bichette’s playoff run was the stuff of legend. After missing nearly two months with a knee injury, he returned just in time for the World Series. He played at second base instead of his customary shortstop.5 He hit 8-for-23 with a home run, and he also walked four times.5 This culminated in a dramatic three-run homer off Shohei Ohtani in the Game 7 loss.1
He has already declared his “free agency desires,” laying his cards on the table.5 This decision is compounded by the public statements of his teammate, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Fresh off signing his own 14-year, $500 million extension in April 5, Guerrero Jr. made the stakes clear: “I would love to finish my career playing with him”.5
The Blue Jays now face a franchise-defining choice. This is not merely a financial calculation. It is a test of their commitment to their $500 million superstar. It also tests their dedication to the entire “win-now” philosophy. The question is simple. What is the price for a hero? This hero is also, by the numbers, a profound defensive liability.
II. Deconstructing the Player: An Elite Bat with a Critical Flaw
Bo Bichette enters the free agent market as one of the most contradictory and polarizing players in recent memory. His value is a tale of two seasons and one glaring, unavoidable flaw.
A. The Offensive Engine (The “Platform Year”)
A player’s “platform year” before free agency is paramount, and Bichette’s 2025 season was a spectacular success. After an injury-plagued 2024, he delivered a necessary “redemption”.7 He slashed an impressive.311/.357/.483 across 139 games.7 He was an offensive engine, racking up 44 doubles, 18 home runs, and 94 RBI.9
Advanced metrics confirm his elite status. He posted a 134 wRC+ (Weighted Runs Created Plus). This means he was 34% better than a league-average hitter and was worth 3.8 fWAR (FanGraphs Wins Above Replacement).9 This performance highlighted his abilities. His heroic World Series re-established him as an elite contact bat. He became one of the premier offensive weapons in baseball.5
B. The 2024 “What If?” (The “Injury Year”)
Any team negotiating against Bichette will point to his disastrous 2024 campaign. He was limited by calf and finger injuries 8 to just 81 games.13 When he was on the field, he was ineffective, hitting a meager.225 with a.598 OPS.13 His 70 wRC+ and -0.3 fWAR 14 were figures more suited to a replacement-level player than a star.
Rival front offices will undoubtedly use this 81-game sample to argue against a $200 million deal. However, the market will almost certainly view 2024 as a “red herring.” Bichette’s 2025 rebound to his career norms (121 OPS+) 14 demonstrates his true talent level. In free agency, teams pay for the established seven-year track record, not the injury-plagued outlier.
C. The Defensive Liability (The “Glove Problem”)
This is the non-negotiable, value-suppressing truth that complicates his entire free-agent case. While Bichette’s bat is elite, his glove is not. Statistically, he is a below-average shortstop. In fact, he is one of the worst defensive players at any position in the sport.15
The 2025 metrics are damning. At shortstop, he posted -12 Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) and a Fielding Run Value (FRV) of -10.16 His -13 Outs Above Average (OAA) ranked last among all qualified shortstops in Major League Baseball.18 This is not a new problem; his career OAA is a staggering -32.18
This profound defensive flaw means that any team signing him is not signing a shortstop. They are signing a “bat” who must be hidden, which leads directly to the most important development of his season.
D. The World Series “Audition”
Bichette’s return from a knee injury for the World Series was contingent on a position change. He began taking ground balls at second base 19 and played the position during the Fall Classic.5 While seemingly a demotion, this was, in fact, a brilliant market-expansion strategy.
The move served as a public audition. It signaled to the entire league that he is not just a flawed shortstop. He is an elite-hitting second baseman. The acquisition became less risky for teams that already have an elite shortstop. Examples include the Los Angeles Dodgers (Mookie Betts) 20 or the New York Mets (Francisco Lindor) 21. His free-agent narrative fundamentally changed from “defensive liability” to “versatile offensive weapon.”
This positional flexibility, paradoxically, may increase his total contract value by bringing more high-payroll bidders to the table.
Table 1: The Two Faces of Bo Bichette (2024 vs. 2025)
| Metric | 2024 (Injury Year) | 2025 (Platform Year) | Career Avg. (2019-2025) |
| Games Played | 81 13 | 139 9 | 107 (per season) |
| Slash Line (AVG/OBP/SLG) | .225 /.277 /.322 14 | .311 /.357 /.483 9 | .294 /.337 /.469 [14, 22] |
| OPS | .598 14 | .840 9 | .806 [14, 22] |
| wRC+ | 70 14 | 134 9 | 122 [12] |
| fWAR | -0.3 14 | 3.8 9 | 20.0 (Total) 9 |
| Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) at SS | -3 [16] | -12 [16] | N/A |
| Outs Above Average (OAA) at SS | 0 [16] | -13 18 | -32 (Career Total) 18 |
III. The Case for Toronto: Why You Don’t Let Your Co-Pilot Walk
The argument for the Blue Jays to re-sign Bichette transcends simple metrics. It is about clubhouse chemistry, market replacement costs, and an organizational mandate set in stone last April.
A. The “Vladdy” Mandate
The Blue Jays’ 2025 season began with the 14-year, $500 million commitment to Vladimir Guerrero Jr..5 A contract of that magnitude is not just an investment in a player. It is an investment in the championship window that player defines. Guerrero’s window is now.
His public plea to “finish my career playing with him” 5 cannot be ignored. Allowing Bichette, a 3.8-WAR player 9 and clubhouse leader, to leave for nothing would be a direct act of organizational sabotage. This is especially true as this $500 million window opens. It would signal to Guerrero that the team is not fully committed to winning. This could poison a 14-year relationship before it has even truly begun. The Vladdy contract essentially required the Blue Jays to re-sign Bichette. The front office may not have realized this commitment at the time.
B. The Offensive Black Hole (The “Plan B” Fallacy)
If Bichette leaves, the Blue Jays’ internal replacement options are not just a “Plan B”; they are a “Plan F.” They are so clearly inadequate that their very existence strengthens Bichette’s negotiating leverage.
- Option 1: Andrés Giménez. The Blue Jays already have Andrés Giménez, a three-time Gold Glove winner, signed long-term.2 He can certainly slide from second base to shortstop.24 The problem? His 2025 season at the plate was an unmitigated disaster. He hit just.210 with a.598 OPS and a 66 OPS+.23 A team fresh off a Game 7 appearance needs a 134 wRC+ bat. They cannot expect to contend with a 66 wRC+ bat. It would be a “white flag” trade-off.
- Option 2: The Prospect Pipeline. The top-level prospects are not ready. Josh Kasevich, a 2022 draftee who reached Triple-A, is a high-floor, “sum-of-his-parts” player.26 He is viewed as a future utility infielder with a good hit tool but (at best) 40-grade power.26 He is not a star. The high-ceiling prospect, 2023 first-rounder Arjun Nimmala, is not expected to be ready until 2028 or 2029.2
C. The Replacement Cost
The free agent market for shortstops behind Bichette is thin.18 The most logical pivot would be to the third base market for Alex Bregman. However, Bregman is projected to receive a contract of six years and $182 million.32 This is almost identical to Bichette’s projection of seven years and $182 million.32 The Blue Jays would be paying the exact same amount of money for an external free agent. This free agent lacks Bichette’s history and intangible value. They would be paying just to fill the offensive hole they chose to create.
IV. The Financial Quagmire: The Case for Letting Him Go
The pragmatic, cold-blooded case for letting Bichette walk is rooted in payroll and pitching. The Blue Jays’ financial commitments are becoming perilously heavy.
A. The “Vladdy” Contract and Payroll Constraints
The Blue Jays have over $850 million in total future commitments.2 Their 2026 payroll is already massive before signing Bichette. Key guaranteed contracts include:
- Vladimir Guerrero Jr.: $480MM through 2039 2
- Andrés Giménez: $86.5MM through 2029 2
- Jose Berrios: $66MM through 2028 2
- Anthony Santander: $65.5MM through 2029 2
- Alejandro Kirk: $52MM through 2030 2
- Kevin Gausman: $23MM through 2026 (final year) 2
- George Springer: $22.5MM through 2026 (final year) 2
The 2026 financial commitment, assuming Shane Bieber’s option, is $164.75 million before paying any arbitration-eligible players like Daulton Varsho (projected $9.7M) and Ernie Clement (projected $4.3M).2 A $27 million AAV for Bichette would increase the payroll past $220 million. This change would severely limit any other moves.33
B. The Desperate Need for Starting Pitching
This is the real crisis. Chris Bassitt ($22M salary in ’25) and Max Scherzer are now free agents.2 This leaves the rotation dangerously thin.
The front office received massive, unexpected good news. Shane Bieber surprisingly exercised his $16 million player option for 2026.14 This was a huge windfall, filling one rotation spot at a below-market rate.
However, even with Bieber, the 2026 rotation (Gausman, Berrios, Bieber, and rookie Trey Yesavage) is thin.34 Worse, both Gausman and Bieber will be free agents after the 2026 season.34 The team must be aggressive in the free agent market for long-term, top-end starters.34
This creates the central organizational dilemma: the choice is not “Bichette vs. Giménez.” It is “Bo Bichette’s Bat vs. Two Frontline Starting Pitchers.” The team has a 2025 payroll of $258 million 33. They likely have around $50-60 million in new AAV to spend. They can either use that on Bichette and a mid-level starter. Alternatively, they might let him walk and sign two $25-30 million AAV arms, like Framber Valdez.31
In this context, Bieber’s $16 million opt-in was a “Deus Ex Machina.” It may have saved Bichette’s Blue Jays career. The opt-in provided just enough financial flexibility to make re-signing him plausible.
V. The Contract: Benchmarks, Projections, and the Second Base “Tax”
There is a strong consensus among market analysts regarding Bichette’s value. The projections are tightly clustered:
- Projection 1: 7 years, $182 million ($26M AAV) 32
- Projection 2: 7 years, $189 million ($27M AAV) 35
- Projection 3: 8 years, $208 million ($26M AAV) 36
A contract is clearly expected. Its average annual value (AAV) is projected between $26-27 million for 7-8 years. This totals $180-$210 million. His value becomes even clearer when compared to his peers.
Table 2: Elite Middle Infield Contract Benchmarks (2022-2026)
| Player (Team) | Year Signed | Age at Signing | Contract (Yrs / $Total) | AAV | Key Skill (at signing) |
| Francisco Lindor (NYM) | 2021 | 27 | 10 Yrs / $341M [37] | $34.1M [37] | Elite Two-Way SS (Glove & Bat) |
| Corey Seager (TEX) | 2021 | 27 | 10 Yrs / $325M [38] | $32.5M [38] | Elite Two-Way SS (Bat & Glove) |
| Trea Turner (PHI) | 2022 | 29 | 11 Yrs / $300M [39] | $27.3M [39] | Elite Bat & Speed / Avg. Glove |
| Dansby Swanson (CHC) | 2022 | 29 | 7 Yrs / $177M 40 | $25.3M 40 | Elite Glove / Avg. Bat |
| Bo Bichette (PROJECTION) | 2025 | 28 | 7-8 Yrs / $182M-$210M | $26M-$27M | Elite Bat / Liability Glove |
The table clearly defines Bichette’s tier. He is not in the $32-34 million AAV class with Seager and Lindor 41; those were elite two-way shortstops.37
The most fascinating comparison is Dansby Swanson.40 Swanson’s elite glove and average bat earned him $177 million. Bichette’s elite bat and awful glove are projected to earn him almost the identical amount.32 This shows the “tax” the market places on bad defense. It effectively pulls Bichette’s AAV down to match Swanson’s total value.
The best benchmark for his AAV is Trea Turner. Turner signed for $27.3 million AAV at age 29, a deal driven entirely by his bat and legs. Bichette, signing at age 28, profiles similarly as a bat-first middle infielder. His AAV should land on that exact number.
VI. The Market: Top Suitors for a 28-Year-Old Offensive Force
If the Blue Jays blink, Bichette’s market is not a 30-team bidding war. Most contending teams already have a long-term, expensive shortstop 18, and most small-market teams “won’t spend the money”.35 This leaves a “two-and-a-half-team” race for his services.
A. The Incumbent: Toronto Blue Jays
The Blue Jays are the most obvious landing spot and the clear favorites.35 They have the exclusive negotiating rights and the emotional connection. They also have the $500 million mandate from Guerrero 5. They have the most to lose by letting him walk.
B. The Top Contender: Los Angeles Dodgers
The Dodgers are Toronto’s worst nightmare. As the “rich get richer” 20, the newly crowned champions 43 are a perfect fit. They are one of the few teams completely indifferent to his defensive flaws; they will pay for the elite bat. Signing Bichette offers them flexibility with Mookie Betts’s position. They can manage the 33-year-old Betts’s decline by moving him to second base and installing Bichette at shortstop. More likely, they will sign Bichette to be their full-time second baseman.20
C. The Wild Card: New York Mets
If owner Steve Cohen wants him, the Mets are always a threat.21 The fit is there: with Lindor at short, Bichette would be signed to play second or third base.21 However, the Mets are already facing astronomical competitive balance tax penalties. They have been over the threshold for four straight years (2022-2025).36 They also must prioritize re-signing Pete Alonso.21 The Mets likely serve as the primary leverage play for Bichette’s agent.
D. The “Connection” Dark Horses
The Atlanta Braves are run by former Jays GM Alex Anthopoulos. The Los Angeles Angels are run by former Jays exec Perry Minasian. Both teams have been mentioned briefly.35 The Braves are highly unlikely. They let the cheaper, glove-first Swanson walk.44 The Angels are not a contending team.
VII. Final Verdict and Recommendation: The $189 Million Decision
This offseason presents the Blue Jays with a clear, if painful, decision. They are a World Series contender anchored by an MVP-caliber first baseman locked in for 14 years.2 Letting his 28-year-old, homegrown “co-pilot” is a non-option. He just posted a 134 wRC+ 9. He also hit a Game 7 World Series home run 7.
It would be a “white flag” on the Guerrero window. The public relations fallout from spurning Vladdy’s request 5 would be franchise-altering. Additionally, the competitive fallout would be significant. It would arise from replacing a 134 wRC+ bat with Andrés Giménez’s 66 wRC+ bat 25.
The payroll is tight, but Shane Bieber’s $16 million opt-in 34 was the miracle the front office needed. It provides just enough flexibility to sign Bichette and one more high-end starting pitcher.
The Blue Jays must re-sign Bo Bichette. Once the contract is signed, the optimal move for the 2026 roster is clear. Bichette should be moved to second base permanently. The elite-gloved Giménez should be slid to shortstop. This alignment maximizes the lineup’s offense. It also improves the team’s up-the-middle defense. This is the exact configuration that should have been in place all along.
The contract will land directly on the Trea Turner AAV benchmark. Toronto will pay him as an elite hitter, not as a shortstop, and will avoid a ninth or tenth year.
Final Contract Prediction: 7 years, $189 million ($27M AAV) with the Toronto Blue Jays.
Works cited
- Key moments from the Dodgers’ wild World Series Game 7 win over the Blue Jays, accessed November 5, 2025, https://apnews.com/article/world-series-game-7-top-moments-cc56abe9a3fd756c445e44ebd62c682d
- Offseason Outlook: Toronto Blue Jays, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/11/offseason-outlook-toronto-blue-jays-16.html
- Blue Jays 2026 Free Agents: 7 Players Not Under Contract Following World Series Loss, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.si.com/mlb/blue-jays-2026-free-agents-7-players-not-under-contract-following-world-series-loss
- Bo Bichette | MLB Contracts & Salaries – Spotrac.com, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.spotrac.com/mlb/player/_/id/19942/bo-bichette
- Blue Jays’ Bo Bichette Declares Free Agency Desires After World Series Loss, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.newsweek.com/sports/mlb/blue-jays-bo-bichette-declares-free-agency-desires-after-world-series-loss-10977765
- Bo Bichette expects to be ready for 2025 World Series – MLB.com, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.mlb.com/news/bo-bichette-expects-to-be-ready-for-2025-world-series
- 4 Offseason Priorities the Blue Jays Can’t Afford to Miss, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.si.com/mlb/bluejays/onsi/news/4-offseason-priorities-blue-jays-cant-afford-miss
- Bo Bichette News – RotoWire, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.rotowire.com/baseball/player/bo-bichette-14310
- Bo Bichette – Stats – Batting | FanGraphs Baseball, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.fangraphs.com/players/bo-bichette/19612/stats?position=SS
- Bo Bichette 2025 Defensive Stats – StatMuse, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.statmuse.com/mlb/ask/bo-bichette-2025-defensive-stats
- MLB trade rumors: Detroit Tigers’ predicted to land $33.6 million Toronto Blue Jays star as Gleyber Torres filler, accessed November 5, 2025, https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/mlb/mlb-trade-rumors-detroit-tigers-predicted-to-land-33-6-million-toronto-blue-jays-star-as-gleyber-torres-filler/articleshow/125098739.cms
- Bo Bichette – Batting Game Logs | FanGraphs Baseball, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.fangraphs.com/players/bo-bichette/19612/game-log?position=SS&season=
- Bo Bichette 2024 Stats | StatMuse, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.statmuse.com/ask?query=bo+bichette+2024+stats&preferred_domain=mlb&direct=true&l=&t=1756252072574
- Bo Bichette Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More | Baseball-Reference.com, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/b/bichebo01.shtml
- Blue Jays Will Greatly Improve in This One Key Area Without Bo Bichette in Lineup, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.si.com/mlb/bluejays/news/blue-jays-will-greatly-improve-this-one-key-area-without-bo-bichette-lineup
- Bo Bichette’s Second Chapter Has Been a Hit So Far | FanGraphs Baseball, accessed November 5, 2025, https://blogs.fangraphs.com/bo-bichettes-second-chapter-has-been-a-hit-so-far/
- Fielding Run Value Leaderboard | baseballsavant.com – MLB.com, accessed November 5, 2025, https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/leaderboard/fielding-run-value
- Previewing The 2025-26 Free Agent Class: Shortstop, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/10/previewing-the-2025-26-free-agent-class-shortstop.html
- Bo Bichette takes ground balls at second base ahead of World Series – MLB.com, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.mlb.com/news/bo-bichette-takes-ground-balls-at-second-base-ahead-of-world-series
- Ranking Bo Bichette’s free agent suitors from favorites to dark horses – FanSided, accessed November 5, 2025, https://fansided.com/mlb/ranking-bo-bichette-s-free-agent-suitors-from-favorites-to-dark-horses
- Bo Bichette Signing With The New York Mets, accessed November 5, 2025, https://twsn.net/2025/11/02/bo-bichette-signing-with-new-york-mets/
- Andrés Giménez Stats, Age, Position, Height, Weight, Fantasy & News | Toronto Blue Jays, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.mlb.com/player/andres-gimenez-665926
- [Chisholm] The Blue Jays are paying $100 million for Andres Gimenez and his dollar store bat. They’re better off without him : r/Torontobluejays – Reddit, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Torontobluejays/comments/1kvx9n7/chisholm_the_blue_jays_are_paying_100_million_for/
- Andrés Giménez Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/g/gimenan01.shtml
- Josh Kasevich Stats & Scouting Report – Baseball America, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.baseballamerica.com/players/17967-josh-kasevich/
- Blue Jays Nation’s 2025 Pre-Season Prospect Countdown – No. 9: Josh Kasevich, accessed November 5, 2025, https://bluejaysnation.com/news/blue-jays-nations-2025-pre-season-prospect-countdown-no-9-josh-kasevich
- Josh Kasevich – Blue Jays Top Prospects | MiLB.com, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/bluejays/josh-kasevich-688460
- Toronto Blue Jays: Josh Kasevich, SS – THREE QUARTER SLOT, accessed November 5, 2025, https://threequarterslot.com/2025/10/30/toronto-blue-jays-josh-kasevich-ss/
- Nimmala – Blue Jays Top Prospects – MLB.com, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/bluejays/arjun-nimmala-805796
- 5 free agents the Blue Jays can sign to finally bring a World Series back to Toronto in 2026, accessed November 5, 2025, https://fansided.com/mlb/5-free-agents-the-blue-jays-can-sign-to-finally-bring-a-world-series-back-to-toronto-in-2026
- Why Blue Jays should reignite their chase of sought after free agent third baseman, accessed November 5, 2025, https://jaysjournal.com/why-blue-jays-should-reignite-their-chase-of-sought-after-free-agent-third-baseman-01k98fchjehe
- 2026 Toronto Blue Jays Payroll | RosterResource | FanGraphs Baseball, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.fangraphs.com/roster-resource/payroll/blue-jays
- Blue Jays’ Free Agency Plans Revealed After Shane Bieber News: Insider, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.newsweek.com/blue-jays-free-agency-plans-revealed-after-shane-bieber-news-insider-10996086
- Bo Bichette free agency: Contract prediction, potential landing spots and more – CBS Sports, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/bo-bichette-free-agency-contract-prediction-landing-spots-blue-jays/
- [Matheson] The best way to look at Bo Bichette’s free agency is that the #BlueJays hold a potential tiebreaker. There will be mutual interest. If another team offers an identical deal, Bichette’s desire to play in Toronto with Vladdy likely wins. Beyond that, it’s free agency. Money wins. : r/Torontobluejays – Reddit, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Torontobluejays/comments/1oocmh9/matheson_the_best_way_to_look_at_bo_bichettes/
- Francisco Lindor | MLB Contracts & Salaries – Spotrac.com, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.spotrac.com/mlb/player/_/id/14113/francisco-lindor
- Corey Seager | MLB Contracts & Salaries – Spotrac.com, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.spotrac.com/mlb/player/_/id/18169/corey-seager
- Trea Turner | MLB Contracts & Salaries – Spotrac.com, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.spotrac.com/mlb/player/_/id/17690/trea-turner
- Dansby Swanson | MLB Contracts & Salaries – Spotrac.com, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.spotrac.com/mlb/player/_/id/17616/dansby-swanson
- What do you think is a fair contract for Bo and Vlad if they were to sign today? : r/Torontobluejays – Reddit, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Torontobluejays/comments/18jdh74/what_do_you_think_is_a_fair_contract_for_bo_and/
- Turner becomes an earner – The Knight Crier, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.knightcrier.org/sports/2022/12/09/turner-becomes-an-earner/
- Could Blue Jays All-Star Change Positions To Join Dodgers? – Newsweek, accessed November 5, 2025, https://www.newsweek.com/could-blue-jays-all-star-change-positions-to-join-dodgers-10985840
- Braves’ first offer to Dansby Swanson revealed – FanSided, accessed November 5, 2025, https://fansided.com/2022/12/04/braves-first-offer-dansby-swanson-revealed/


Leave a comment